By Georgia Johnson
We’re just a week out from the holiday where pies make an attempt to outshine a fully dressed bird. With that in mind, here’s how your pie crust will steal the show.
Use cold butter for fat in the crust. It’s more flavorful, minimally processed. Shortening is a hydrogenated fat, oil that’s chemically made solid and not healthy. Leaf lard is more expensive, but leads to a crust that is more crumbly, less flakey. Oils tend to have a sandy texture, and prove to be less flakey at the one time flakey is important.
The butter you use does not need to be frozen, just cold. Be sure to chill the finished dough for at least 30 minutes before rolling out. Keep your hands cold and handle the dough as little as possible. Gluten loves kneaded dough, the pie crust nemesis. OK, go ahead and use your food processor, but pulse judiciously.
If you are making your pie crust ahead, chilling or freezing it, adding a ½ teaspoon of white vinegar will keep the dough from turning gray.
Rub 1 teaspoon of butter over the bottom and sides of your pie tin and place in the freezer while making the dough. After rolling out dough, place it quickly into the tin, add the cold filling and get it in the oven at 450 degrees. Place on the bottom rack first to brown the bottom crust for 12 minutes, then move to the middle rack for another 12 minutes. Turn to 375 and bake 30 to 40 minutes more for a two-crust pie (a pie with a layer of crust on top).
Use flour for thickening an apple pie. Use tapioca for a berry pie. Any commercial jelling product is highly processed and expensive. Cornstarch tends to reverse from thickening when the temperature is too high. It also loses its properties after a time and pools on the bottom crust you worked so hard to keep crisp.
For pumpkin, pecan and fruit-based one-crust pies, blind bake (don’t add filling yet) the crust at 450 degrees with a layer of tin foil (or silicon mat) on top and pouring in beans or using ceramic pie weights for 15 minutes to keep the crust from rising up. Remove beans and brush with a bit of egg wash which will dry quickly and create a barrier between crust and filling as it bakes at 375 until set. Crust decorations can be cut and baked ahead, then pressed into the top of a custard-type pie. Sprinkle cut-outs liberally with that big sparkling sugar.
Have a blessed Thanksgiving. May your bottoms be crisp and flakey.
Georgia Johnson is a food wrangler, poet and rebel.


